I would definitely prefer one in the lower tax bracket but first & foremost it needs to be a clean & well maintained example. Once I’ve exhausted my search then I will look at the higher tax band too. I did say it must be 5 door for the practicality & I actually prefer the look. I used to own both a 3 door mk4 & high tax band Mk5 back in the day. I need a good daily for the winter whilst the RS is sorn’d & I think the R32 will be perfect.